3D column chart, stacked

[waeltlmi]

Hello,

I created a 3D chart of the type 3D Column Chart from the standard tzpe menu.
see following picture:

3D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/MyhouTEW.jpg

X Achsis: driven kilometre in 10000 blocks
Y Achsis: Production month
Z Achsis: number

I need to show another month in that chart, the repair month.
Each colored column should be a stacked column with more colors, so that
every color shows a repair month.
the chart should look like the following but 3 dimensional:

2D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/d88eP7Cx.jpg

That is a stacked column chart with 3 D effect from the standard types.
it is not really 3 dimensional, the timeline is missing. I think what I need
acctually is a combination of both charts, but I cant find a solution.
Maybe it is possible with VBA or excel has another possibility to combine
charts.
Many thanks for help!

regards,
Michael

 

[Jon Peltier]

Forget the 3D chart. Please.

Why not make a clustered-stacked column chart, which is really a stacked
column chart with carefully arranged data. This page links to a number of
examples of these charts:

http://peltiertech.com/Excel/ChartsHowTo/ClusterStack.html

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Peltier Technical Services
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
http://PeltierTech.com/
_______

 

[waeltlmi]

Hi Jon,

I have already had a look at your website and I´ve found some useful
information like that excel can´t combine that chart types. your website is
really good.
but normally there should be a possibility to do that with VB.
VB could maybe use that Excel functions in another way/sequence or create a
charttype out of different chart functions....
Maybe someone knows more...

regards,
Michael

Forget the 3D chart. Please.

Why not make a clustered-stacked column chart, which is really a stacked
column chart with carefully arranged data. This page links to a number of
examples of these charts:

http://peltiertech.com/Excel/ChartsHowTo/ClusterStack.html

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Peltier Technical Services
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
http://PeltierTech.com/
_______

Hello,

I created a 3D chart of the type 3D Column Chart from the standard tzpe
menu.
see following picture:

3D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/MyhouTEW.jpg

X Achsis: driven kilometre in 10000 blocks
Y Achsis: Production month
Z Achsis: number

I need to show another month in that chart, the repair month.
Each colored column should be a stacked column with more colors, so that
every color shows a repair month.
the chart should look like the following but 3 dimensional:

2D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/d88eP7Cx.jpg

That is a stacked column chart with 3 D effect from the standard types.
it is not really 3 dimensional, the timeline is missing. I think what I
need
acctually is a combination of both charts, but I cant find a solution.
Maybe it is possible with VBA or excel has another possibility to combine
charts.
Many thanks for help!

regards,
Michael

 

[waeltlmi]

Hi Jon,

thanks for your reply, I have already had a look on your website, it´s
really good, I have found some useful information.
You wrote that Excel cannot combine these two chart types, but shouldn´t
there be a possibility to do that with VB?
I mean maybe a VB Excel Macro could use the Excel functions in another
way/sequence. then you could create an own chart type...
I think it should be possible theoretically, but practically I don´t know VB
and the functions...

regards,
Michael

Forget the 3D chart. Please.

Why not make a clustered-stacked column chart, which is really a stacked
column chart with carefully arranged data. This page links to a number of
examples of these charts:

http://peltiertech.com/Excel/ChartsHowTo/ClusterStack.html

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Peltier Technical Services
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
http://PeltierTech.com/
_______

Hello,

I created a 3D chart of the type 3D Column Chart from the standard tzpe
menu.
see following picture:

3D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/MyhouTEW.jpg

X Achsis: driven kilometre in 10000 blocks
Y Achsis: Production month
Z Achsis: number

I need to show another month in that chart, the repair month.
Each colored column should be a stacked column with more colors, so that
every color shows a repair month.
the chart should look like the following but 3 dimensional:

2D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/d88eP7Cx.jpg

That is a stacked column chart with 3 D effect from the standard types.
it is not really 3 dimensional, the timeline is missing. I think what I
need
acctually is a combination of both charts, but I cant find a solution.
Maybe it is possible with VBA or excel has another possibility to combine
charts.
Many thanks for help!

regards,
Michael

 

[Jon Peltier]

There's nothing magical about VB (please don't tell my clients!). VB allows
you to automate most (not quite all) of what you can do manually, and it
does provide some shortcuts to what you could do tediously by hand. VB does
not provide any new built in chart types or other graphical features.

The problems with 3D charts include that they are hard to make in such a way
as to accurately represent the data; and that most people making charts
don't even realize their data is not accurately represented, because they
are busy with (blinded by) formatting issues. Excel can't really handle 3
dimensions of data in a Cartesian manner, but most people don't have
Cartesian data anyway. Most of their data is only 2D, so the third dimension
is misleading in that it gives a false impression of a third spatial
dimension. If the data has multiple dimensions, the added dimensions are
usually categorical, so laying them out along a third spatial dimension is
unnecessary; a clustered or stacked chart provides a suitable representation
of the data.

You could make a stacked 3D column chart, but you have to make multiple
charts (stacked column charts with 3D effects), one for each value of the 3d
dimension (so the data must be categorical along this dimension). You have
to make most of the front charts transparent or invisible, then you have to
align the charts carefully, so the third dimension recedes properly into the
page. What VB can do for you is automate this process, track the visible and
hidden chart elements, and handle all of the alignment.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Peltier Technical Services
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
http://PeltierTech.com/
_______

Hi Jon,

thanks for your reply, I have already had a look on your website, it´s
really good, I have found some useful information.
You wrote that Excel cannot combine these two chart types, but shouldn´t
there be a possibility to do that with VB?
I mean maybe a VB Excel Macro could use the Excel functions in another
way/sequence. then you could create an own chart type...
I think it should be possible theoretically, but practically I don´t know
VB
and the functions...

regards,
Michael

Forget the 3D chart. Please.

Why not make a clustered-stacked column chart, which is really a stacked
column chart with carefully arranged data. This page links to a number of
examples of these charts:

http://peltiertech.com/Excel/ChartsHowTo/ClusterStack.html

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Peltier Technical Services
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
http://PeltierTech.com/
_______

Hello,

I created a 3D chart of the type 3D Column Chart from the standard tzpe
menu.
see following picture:

3D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/MyhouTEW.jpg

X Achsis: driven kilometre in 10000 blocks
Y Achsis: Production month
Z Achsis: number

I need to show another month in that chart, the repair month.
Each colored column should be a stacked column with more colors, so
that
every color shows a repair month.
the chart should look like the following but 3 dimensional:

2D:

http://www.directupload.net/show/d/567/d88eP7Cx.jpg

That is a stacked column chart with 3 D effect from the standard types.
it is not really 3 dimensional, the timeline is missing. I think what I
need
acctually is a combination of both charts, but I cant find a solution.
Maybe it is possible with VBA or excel has another possibility to
combine
charts.
Many thanks for help!

regards,
Michael