Hi Rachel,
with a macro that prints a page for each print,
by customizing, printing a page, customizing, printing the next page, etc.
Probably not worth the effort but it can be done.
Headings for Columns, and Page Numbering
http://www.mvps.org/dmcritchie/excel/headcols.htm#restart
Much simpler is to not print headers at all but to use header rows and
delay the start so the first page does not have the headers rows.
-- but then these are really excel headers and
there is nothing along this avenue for different footers.