David E.,
I've had great respect for your technical knowledge for as long as I've been
reading your answers.
However, this sounds like something an American would say. (I assume you are
an Aussie from the "dot au" in your name.)
"It is not *my* fault." "It has to be someone *else's* fault." We currently
have a culture of no one taking responsibility for themselves in this
country. Arrrg...
Based on the fact that I have several computers it works on, another person
in this thread said that it works on his computer, and all of my client's
computers that I've checked, (I never mentioned them before,) I find it very
difficult to blame Access or Microsoft.
Dave (the OP) never mentioned that he didn't have any non-Microsoft software
on the machine. And he never mentioned that he had run a memory test or any
other hardware tests on his computer.
Not having the machine sitting here, it's very hard to say exactly what the
problem is. It could be the hardware. Or it could be the software
installation. Or it could just be the database itself is corrupted. One way
or the other, it *is* Dave's computer and database, so it *is* his
responsibility to trouble shoot the problem or take it to someone that can.
I offered to send Dave a database with this feature working so that he can
at least rule out his database as being the problem. (He never accepted the
offer.)
It's not a matter of supporting the "odd one out" of a hundred that don't
work. It's the "odd one out" owner's responsibility to trouble shoot their
computer and get it fixed. I've had way too many "odd one out's" over the
last 20+ years. It's always been the computer (hardware or corrupted
software) in the end.
Until Dave rules out the mdb file, (my offer to send a test database still
stands,) it is his responsibility to reinstall the software, or fix the
hardware, or live with the problem.
I did a quick Google search for access report openargs. (I didn't spend a
long time.) I found a lot of people recommending using this feature. (I just
can't imagine anyone recommending a feature that has even random "know
problems.") I found a bunch of people that had problems because of miss-use.
I found no one reporting that the feature didn't work.
Although I am a big Access (and Microsoft) supporter, if you've followed my
answers around here for very long, you know that I don't hesitate to blame
Access (or Microsoft) when it *is* their problem.
Until there is at least a second person reporting that the feature is not
working, I stand firm that it is not Access' (or Microsoft's) problem. There
are just way too many people reporting that it *is* working to blame
anything other than the computer, hardware and/or software.
Sco
M.L. "Sco" Scofield, Microsoft Access MVP, MCSD, MCP, MSS, A+
Denver Area Access Users Group Vice President
www.DAAUG.org
MS Colorado Events Administrator
www.MSColoradoEvents.com
Useful Metric Conversion #18 of 19: 8 nickels = 2 paradigms (My personal
favorite)
Miscellaneous Access and VB "stuff" at
www.ScoBiz.com