In Excel, how can I tell the program to disallow duplicate data i.

G

gthawkster

I would like to use a column to identity each row in a list as a separate
item #. I can't have duplicates in this column and would like the program to
prevent someone from entering an ID# in twice. Any ideas?
 
H

Harlan Grove

Jason Morin wrote...
To help prevent accidential copying and pasting over Validation cells, you could
employ this technique from J. Walkenbach:

http://j-walk.com/ss/excel/tips/tip98.htm
....

Not reliable. At least not for XL97.

Given the setup in this tip, define validation as whole numbers between 0
and 10. Enter -500. Excel will display a dialog about the invalid entry.
Click the Retry button (or press [Enter]), then press [Ctrl]+C, [Esc],
[Ctrl]+V in sequence. Voila - there's an invalid entry in the cell that the
wonderful Change event handler did squat all to prevent. Pasting *text* into
cells leaves validation rules as-is, though completely ignored. This is also
true for pasting special as values. Excel's Data Validation is a toy feature
providing no more true security than worksheet or workbook protection
passwords.

The only *SECURE* way to implement validation involves both using Calculate
event handlers and hardcoding the validation rules within them to provide
entry-time validation, *and* using formulas, possibly in defined names, to
check all critical cells and return error values if there are any invalid
entries or innocuous values if all cells contain valid entries. Then use
those check values in all downstream calculations to ensure that *ANY*
invalid entries result in *ALL* downstream formulas returning error values.
*NOTHING* gets users to clean up their entries quicker than giving them
NOTHING BUT GARBAGE if they're careless or worse.
 
H

Harlan Grove

gthawkster said:
I would like to use a column to identity each row in a list as a separate
item #. I can't have duplicates in this column and would like the program
to prevent someone from entering an ID# in twice. Any ideas?

How exactly is your workbook used by these other users? What sort of ID #s
are they entering? Are your users assigning these ID #s themselves? If so,
computers are MUCH, MUCH BETTER at generating unique ID #s or serial #s than
humans, so it may be better to have the workbook generate these #s.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top