Failed left intendation; this time polite :o)

G

Gerry Rudolf

Dear Beth!

I apologize for having been impolite. I appreciate the
time you invested into it. Now I have spent an hour to
describe exactly the steps it takes to make you see what I
am referring to. I hope that this will work out for you.
Please let me know about your results. This issue I had,
as far as I remember, since Word 6.0, but maybe even
before that.

Document setup:
- letter size, portrait
- print layout view
- margins: 15 mm left and right, 20 mm top and bottom;
header & footer at 12.7 mm
- Font/Font Size: Times New Roman 10 pts
- Line spacing: exact 11.6 pt
- Space between paragraphs: none

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Create new document as described above for the sake of
demonstration (though any other document size or font type
and size as well as line spacing will do, too.)
2. Type "excths " and copy it repeatedly in blocks of 100,
blocks separated by hard paragraph breaks, until a little
over a page is produced. (Any other text will do, too.)
3. document rendered as two columns with 5 mm spacing in
between for demonstration purpose (any other spacing will
do, too, also three column or even single column
rendering, provided table reaches from the right into
paragraph with left indentation, see below).
4. insert a paragraph return after the first paragraph on
first page
5. mark this paragraph break sign, convert it to table
with presets, resulting in a single-cell table 94.2 mm
wide, 3.8 mm Space between columns, border ½ pt single
stroke solid. (Any other table will do, as long as it is
considerably less wide than the text area)
6. change height of cell to exactly 100 pt; width to 120 mm
7. mark entire table
8a. turn table into a floating frame and arrange floating
table at: Horizontal Position = left from Margin, Vertical
Position = Bottom from Margin.
8b. Or alternatively, table can be dragged on the four-
arrow-handle at the top left to make it floating at the
lower left corner of the text area, or Table/Table
Properties/Positioning is set to the above 8a. values. The
result will be the same.
9. change paragraph formatting of last(!) paragraph on
first page to "Left Indentation = 10 mm" = 38 px

10. Result: The left indentation is rendered properly at
areas of the paragraph, were no floating table intrudes
from the right, but it disappears to the right of the
table. The distance between the text and the table is
defined by the horizontal (right) margin of the floating
frame/table positioning. If that is reset to zero, the
text will start right next to the table.

11. place cursor at beginning of last line on first page.
Now move with arrow-right key to the right. The cursor
will vanish well before the last "excths", as this is
already supposed to be rendered on the next page
12. Mark first "excths" on the second page.
13. Switch to normal view. Scroll a little upward without
moving the cursor in order to be able to see two lines
above the marked "excths"
14. Note that now two "excths" are marked!
15. Move the cursor: The first marking disappears (where
the real cursor is), the second does only after a repaint.
16 Move back to the once properly marked "excths," mark
it, and change its text color to red and leave the word
marked.
17 Switch back to Print layout view without moving the cur-
sor.
18. Note that you have two marked, red words, one on each
page.
19. move the cursor twice to the right with the arrow-
right key, then press "Home" to go to the beginning of the
last line on the first page.
20 . Now try to move to the red word on this last line of
the first page an try to mark it by keeping the shift key
pressed and moving with the arrow keys.

Have Fun!

This happens ALWAYS. No matter which document setup, font
style, size, columns, or what have you, no matter if
frames, floating tables or other objects. The only
prerequisite is that a floating object needs to intrude
from the right into the column of a paragraph that is
supposed to have a left indentation. Even floating
pictures, wordart, cliparts have these effect. Try it! It
can make you nuts to figure out which word belongs on
which line and on which page, and it sure drives Word
nuts, as under certain circumstances the line and page
breaks are unstable.
 
B

Beth Melton

Hi Gerry,

Thanks for understanding the need to be to each other around here -
otherwise these groups would ultimately degrade and benefit no one.
:)

And thank you for the repro steps - they helped a lot!

Now I can see the problem you describe: The Left indent for the
paragraph is disregarded and the Table property: "Distance from
surrounding text" is used instead.

I noted previously you indicated the printed document is correct
however my printed version was the same as the display.

One portion of your repro steps I could not duplicate were steps 11 -
20.

If I used the right arrow key to navigate to the end of the line then
the cursor did not disappear, it moved to the beginning of the first
paragraph on the second page as expected. Nor did highlighting the
first word on the second page result in multiple words selected when I
switched to Print Layout view.

Attempting to determine the beginning/end of a 'page' when your
document contains multiple columns or floating images in Normal view
is fruitless since Normal view is not WYSIWYG and pagination will not
be correct since columns and floating images are suppressed.

I tried this in various versions of Word but as an attempt to narrow
this down, what version of Word are you using? Take a look under
Help/About and please provide the full version number.

Please post all follow-up questions to the newsgroup. Requests for
assistance by email can not be acknowledged.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Beth Melton
Microsoft Office MVP

Word FAQ: http://mvps.org/word
TechTrax eZine: http://mousetrax.com/techtrax/
MVP FAQ site: http://mvps.org/


Dear Beth!

I apologize for having been impolite. I appreciate the
time you invested into it. Now I have spent an hour to
describe exactly the steps it takes to make you see what I
am referring to. I hope that this will work out for you.
Please let me know about your results. This issue I had,
as far as I remember, since Word 6.0, but maybe even
before that.

Document setup:
- letter size, portrait
- print layout view
- margins: 15 mm left and right, 20 mm top and bottom;
header & footer at 12.7 mm
- Font/Font Size: Times New Roman 10 pts
- Line spacing: exact 11.6 pt
- Space between paragraphs: none

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Create new document as described above for the sake of
demonstration (though any other document size or font type
and size as well as line spacing will do, too.)
2. Type "excths " and copy it repeatedly in blocks of 100,
blocks separated by hard paragraph breaks, until a little
over a page is produced. (Any other text will do, too.)
3. document rendered as two columns with 5 mm spacing in
between for demonstration purpose (any other spacing will
do, too, also three column or even single column
rendering, provided table reaches from the right into
paragraph with left indentation, see below).
4. insert a paragraph return after the first paragraph on
first page
5. mark this paragraph break sign, convert it to table
with presets, resulting in a single-cell table 94.2 mm
wide, 3.8 mm Space between columns, border ½ pt single
stroke solid. (Any other table will do, as long as it is
considerably less wide than the text area)
6. change height of cell to exactly 100 pt; width to 120 mm
7. mark entire table
8a. turn table into a floating frame and arrange floating
table at: Horizontal Position = left from Margin, Vertical
Position = Bottom from Margin.
8b. Or alternatively, table can be dragged on the four-
arrow-handle at the top left to make it floating at the
lower left corner of the text area, or Table/Table
Properties/Positioning is set to the above 8a. values. The
result will be the same.
9. change paragraph formatting of last(!) paragraph on
first page to "Left Indentation = 10 mm" = 38 px

10. Result: The left indentation is rendered properly at
areas of the paragraph, were no floating table intrudes
from the right, but it disappears to the right of the
table. The distance between the text and the table is
defined by the horizontal (right) margin of the floating
frame/table positioning. If that is reset to zero, the
text will start right next to the table.

11. place cursor at beginning of last line on first page.
Now move with arrow-right key to the right. The cursor
will vanish well before the last "excths", as this is
already supposed to be rendered on the next page
12. Mark first "excths" on the second page.
13. Switch to normal view. Scroll a little upward without
moving the cursor in order to be able to see two lines
above the marked "excths"
14. Note that now two "excths" are marked!
15. Move the cursor: The first marking disappears (where
the real cursor is), the second does only after a repaint.
16 Move back to the once properly marked "excths," mark
it, and change its text color to red and leave the word
marked.
17 Switch back to Print layout view without moving the cur-
sor.
18. Note that you have two marked, red words, one on each
page.
19. move the cursor twice to the right with the arrow-
right key, then press "Home" to go to the beginning of the
last line on the first page.
20 . Now try to move to the red word on this last line of
the first page an try to mark it by keeping the shift key
pressed and moving with the arrow keys.

Have Fun!

This happens ALWAYS. No matter which document setup, font
style, size, columns, or what have you, no matter if
frames, floating tables or other objects. The only
prerequisite is that a floating object needs to intrude
from the right into the column of a paragraph that is
supposed to have a left indentation. Even floating
pictures, wordart, cliparts have these effect. Try it! It
can make you nuts to figure out which word belongs on
which line and on which page, and it sure drives Word
nuts, as under certain circumstances the line and page
breaks are unstable.
 
B

Beth Melton

Hi Gerry,

Follow-up to my previous post: if you go to
Tools/Options/Compatibility are your Compatibility options set for the
version of Word you are using?

If I change the Compatibility Options to "Word 6.0/95" and use the
right arrow to navigate the paragraph, when the cursor disappears the
right indent marker on the ruler bar appears as a negative right
indent and the text does seem to paginate unexpectedly. However if I
change the Compatibility options then this behavior does not occur.

--
Please post all follow-up questions to the newsgroup. Requests for
assistance by email can not be acknowledged.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Beth Melton
Microsoft Office MVP

Word FAQ: http://mvps.org/word
TechTrax eZine: http://mousetrax.com/techtrax/
MVP FAQ site: http://mvps.org/
 
B

Beth Melton

Another follow-up - Sorry - I keep thinking of new things to try! lol

If I print the document with Compatibility set for Word 6.0/95 then I
am able to reproduce the printing behavior as well.

I'm not 100% certain this would be considered is a bug but "by design"
instead.

In Word 6/95 if you wanted to suppress an indent around floating
objects then this would not be easy to accomplish - at first glance it
appears to be impossible to accomplish with a single paragraph.

In order to accommodate both an indent offset to the image wrap and a
suppressed indent then the only way I can see to accomplish this is to
reverse the behavior. This way you can easily change the "Distance
from text" to accomplish the desired wrapping behavior.

For example if the paragraph has a .5" indent and the "Distance from
text" is 13" then set the "Distance from text" to .63". Of course if
the floating object is moved to a paragraph that does not have a left
indent you would need to change the "Distance from text" but at least
as of Word 97 either scenario can be accommodated.

--
Please post all follow-up questions to the newsgroup. Requests for
assistance by email can not be acknowledged.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Beth Melton
Microsoft Office MVP

Word FAQ: http://mvps.org/word
TechTrax eZine: http://mousetrax.com/techtrax/
MVP FAQ site: http://mvps.org/
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top